Home > IN > Love Where You Live > Redkey, Indiana, Finds New Life With Revitalized Downtown

Redkey, Indiana, Finds New Life With Revitalized Downtown

A small town once left for dead, Redkey, Indiana, is booming back to life.

By Emily Lansdell on June 17, 2022

The former Gray Hotel building in Redkey, Indiana
Nathan Lambrecht

For years, locals around the small community of Redkey would sometimes call it “Deadkey.” With a population barely over 1,400, the town was too often known for its dilapidated and empty storefronts in a once thriving historic downtown.

Rewriting the future, a small but mighty force of Redkey residents and business owners decided to resurrect the area. What started with a few old buildings full of potential is now an active intersection of dining, shopping, entertainment and events.

Tressa Ward prepares pizza in the oven at the Lil Bistro in Redkey.
Nathan Lambrecht

Booming Back to Life

Incorporated in 1883 and once located on a gas field, Redkey was a hub of the “gas boom.” As the boom fizzled and time marched on, its downtown succumbed to deterioration like many small towns across the U.S.

Travis Richards, executive director for the Jay County Development Corp., says ongoing revitalization efforts gained momentum as part of a countywide plan in 2017.

“There were a number of empty buildings,” Richards says. “The focus was to try to save them and fill them and create a thriving area.”

Residents began to see new light posts, landscaping, signage and charming sidewalk renovations. This evolving backdrop was becoming the perfect setting for business growth, but also fun, family events like the annual Gas Boom Days or the Junior League Firecracker Tournament in July.

Jason Robbins looks at a set of lamps for sale at the Redkey Junction in Redkey.
Nathan Lambrecht
Redkey Junktion

All In This Together

Mark and Shelli Leavell contributed to Redkey’s rebirth after expanding their antique store in a two-story building called Redkey Junktion. This successful location also houses apartments overlooking downtown and 17 antique vendors with a waiting list for more.

“Rather than trying to compete with the big stores, we are offering things that they don’t,” Mark Leavell says. “The downtown stores work together. We know that people are much more likely to come to town to visit several stores rather than just one.”

“The downtown stores work together. We know that people are much more likely to come to town to visit several stores rather than just one.”

Mark Leavell | Redkey Junktion

And coming to town they are, says Constance Hill, co-owner of the Key Palace Theater and the recently reopened Key Diner. When she and husband, Brian, responded to an ad to run the diner, they had no idea what they were getting into, she says. They weren’t even blues fans, but now they run the diner and the blues theater that has seen acts like B.B. King and Buddy Guy in its 109-year history. Today, they host contemporary blues artists and many local acts.

“We have been welcomed into Redkey like no other,” Hill says. “They know we’re not from here, but they don’t care. The attitude is, ‘What are we going to do next?’”

Jason Murphy, left, learns how to make a knife out of a railroad tie with help from Derik Lucas at the Redkey Blacksmith in Redkey.
Nathan Lambrecht
Redkey Blacksmith

Jeff Miller, owner of Corner Store Vintage, is one longtime resident who welcomes the growth at his popular mid-century modern antique store. He added a second location across the street to meet the demand for shoppers who appreciate his eye for designer Danish modern furniture, vintage electronics, and the occasional pink flamingo or orange Naugahyde chair.

A highlight of downtown is a collection of huge, hand-painted murals featuring old-time advertisers such as Gold Medal Flour and Mail Pouch tobacco on the sides of some of the buildings. The murals, National Historic Monuments, are a popular photo opportunity for visitors.

The variety in the two-block downtown district only strengthens local business in a spirit of cooperation, not competition, Miller says.

“We want people to come and spend all day, not just an hour,” Miller says. “With 90 percent of our business coming from out of town, we want it to be a destination.”

Brian Hill, right, serves Robert, left, Jolene and Zayne Fair breakfast at the Key Palace Diner in Redkey.
Nathan Lambrecht

Destination Downtown

One new popular stop for visitors and residents alike is Redkey Blacksmiths LLC. Owner Leroy Brown leads classes teaching the art of hand-forged knifemaking. Students enjoy a meal from local eateries like the Lil Bistro as part of this unique experience, Brown says. “People are coming alive in my classes. It’s a real thing,” says Brown, who plans to add ax throwing just a few doors down.

The growing district also offers up encounters with the paranormal at the historic Haunted Gray Hotel, now converted into multiple storefronts, which include The Kindred Spirit New Age shop and the SPPI Ghost Hunters tours.

The downtown opera house built in 1892 also serves as a downtown event venue.

“If we can convince bigger city people to come to our small town with … experiences you can’t get anywhere else, then we flip the switch,” Brown says. “We have something really nice to offer – a sunset instead of a skyscraper.”

Array ( [0] => 160571 [1] => 160549 [2] => 154925 [3] => 111972 [4] => 111961 [5] => 111954 [6] => 157090 [7] => 79922 )
Array ( )
Array ( )
Array ( [0] => 160571 [1] => 160549 [2] => 154925 [3] => 111972 [4] => 111961 [5] => 111954 [6] => 157090 [7] => 79922 )

More To Read

Newsletter Sign Up

Keep up to date with our latest rankings and articles!
Enter your email to be added to our mailing list.